Dotsisx

Dotsisx, aka Rita El Khoury, joined Symbian-Guru.com in September of 2007, and has been writing awesome content ever since. Rita often explores the normal user aspect of Symbian-powered devices, and offers in-depth thoughts on various topics. You can follow Dotsisx on Twitter at @Khouryrt

If you enjoyed this post, be sure to subscribe to Symbian-Guru.com's RSS feed to stay up to date on future articles. You can also follow us on Twitter: @SymbianGuru


  • http://thenokianetwork.com Steve Rowlands

    Couldn’t agree with you more Rita on all those points.

    The build quality issues (the light leakage, as you pointed out, is a complete joke) were enough for me to send the device back. A bit more metal used here and there in the chassis would have improved the build quality massively.

  • Beowulf

    Of the issues you pointed out the camera is the deal-breaker for me. I almost bought a 52 or 55 but I need a camera that can take good close-range photos (mainly to use as a scanner for documents and notes) and for that a good autofocus camera will do a lot better.

    I was a bit surprised about the build quality aspecs, especially that prying out thing.

    I will probably buy a Nokia E72 (better camera, more memory) this weekend and I hope overall build quality is a bit better.

    Regarding your application-shortcut comment, I agree, but perhaps it will be easy to tweak in future firmware versions if Nokia cares about it.

  • henry

    How’s the signal strength when compared against the older e51?

  • Lebanese

    How can we be sure that this unit in brand new? or at least this isnt a demo unit? i am surprised to see such review while the handset itself is great.

    I wonder how credible this review is based on the handset u got!

  • http://www.symbian-guru.com TheGuru

    Our review units come directly from Nokia, Lebanese. They are all production units, unless otherwise specified in the review.

  • http://www.symbian-guru.com Dotsisx

    @ Lebanese,
    The E52 I have is a unit I picked up last Friday from the headquarters of Nokia Lebanon, it’s a production unit E52 with final software and was never dropped on the floor (by me). I thought that this particular unit had the light leakage issues as well as the front plate peeling, but if you take a look around the internet, you’ll see these problems mentioned everywhere, and not only in Lebanon. Besides, I also had the same issue with a production E55 from Nokia France, so it’s hard to question the credibility of two units from two different countries.

  • Fredrik

    The black E52 was released here in Sweden about ~6 weeks ago and I was one of the first to get one, and I totally agree with the build quality issues. One of the major reasons to get an E-series device used to be because of the superior build quality, but it seems like Nokia gone cheap with the E-series now too. They should have used more metal.

    Not something that gonna make me stop using the device though, but I’m no longer as loyal to Nokia as I used to be and will look more at the others the next time I buy a phone.

  • Lebanese

    i hardly see the reason for seeking fame by bashing others… i simply dont agree on your review and you should accept this and the answer by “TheGuru” was very sufficient for me and understandable before u jump into attack mode “Dotsisx”.

    Anyways this site is a very well know site for its credibility and information posted on it is globally recognized cant understand why it accepted such a low level review and a LATE one!

  • imran

    the worst part is the inbuilt memory of only 60mb.

  • Bushlaibi

    @Lebanese
    I really don’t know, but I can hardly see that dotsisx “bashed” you in her reply as you have stated. The reply is totaly acceptable and is within discussion limits. If you cant take normal replies, or cant DIFFERENTIATE between a “bashing” reply and a normal one, then I recommend you cool of from commenting on blogs for a while.
    And yes, the E52 has terrible build quality as an E series phone.

  • Lebanese

    @Bushlaibi

    yeah sure i am so intimidated by your reply that i would really think of taking time off…

    anyways not u or anyone will force me not to read this great site as i am a regular here and a fan of “TheGuru” but the last time i checked we are in a free world and i am entitled to my opinion whether u like it or not.

    The build of the e52 is bad and its highlighted either in this article or many places on the net and thats a fact that we cannot argue about… but the problem is that the author of this article cannot accept someone questioning her information and the only real and convincing answer was already presented by “The Guru” and that would have been enough and ended all debates but she preferred to attack or jump into defensive mode as if she knew that she was wrong somewhere…

  • Hoffi

    Dear Dotsisx!
    In spite of your warnings I bought the E52 just before Christmas. It was not so easy to get one here in Germany with a black keypad, but Steve Litchfield “told us” to wait for it – and he is right.
    I strongly agree with you, the build quality of the E52 is embarrassing for E-Series. I bought it, 'cause I was sick of the E51 battery, but the E52 lacks a lot of things. The menu-keys are too small, the whole keypad is much behind the one of the E51 and the display is larger but with the same resolution. This makes some small symbols blurred. Does anyone remember the perfect display of the E60? It has a higher resolution and is really admirable.
    So, Nokia: wake up! Give us a candybar worth to bear the “E” in its name – and worth to give us our money. And btw: yes, we are willing to pay a lot of money for a real, Psion-like Communicator. This is not only a hardware-thing, we need a Calendar and a Contact-Application for business-use, not for fun.
    Thank you Dotsisx for your great work!

  • Alcatraz

    Hi Rita,

    I agree the light leaks are annoying, but there's one thing even more annoying for me, but I don't know if it's an E52 issue or an FP2 issue.

    I never want to use my E52 in landscape mode, as I prefer portrait mode for everything, including emails, so I turn the Sensor off. However, when I do, I'm forced to use the image viewer in landscape mode! This is crazy! If I turn the sensor on, I can use the image viewer in two modes, but then I've got to put up with the screen changing orientation each time I move one way or another.

    If you know the right people in Nokia, please ask them to correct this anomaly with a bug fix.

    Keep up the great work and balanced reports!

  • mohamedshafi

    I have bought one NOKIA E52 mobile, I could not install any sofware like opera, mobile dialer error coming please help me.

  • http://www.symbian-guru.com khouryrt

    Agreed. Hardware + decent PIM applications are a must for Eseries users. And thanks for the compliment :)

  • http://www.symbian-guru.com khouryrt

    Ouch, never paid attention to this point. I used to turn off autorotation, as I hate how it sometimes happens when I don't want it to, but given the surreal amount of devices I review / try / own, and how many times I reset them, I eventually had to accept the fact that autorotation is here to stay and adapted. So I never noticed that error.

  • alcatraz

    Thanks Rita. I just found another weird bug today.

    I don't keep my SMS files for very long (usually only a day or two), so my Inbox and Sent folders are often empty, like they were about 1 hour ago …… or so I thought.

    When I sent an SMS to a friend from my handset, I can only see one item in my Sent Folder, as expected. However, when I clicked on that SMS to check my message, I noticed the top of the screen showed 1/3 messages! When I scrolled to the right, I saw the last two emails I sent from my handset.

    In other words, the Sent folder only displays SMS sent, but not Emails sent UNLESS you firstly open one of the SMS. Is that weird or what? Maybe my handset is the CIA version!

    :)

  • the1beard

    E52 = rubbish

    Not an e51 replacement the build quality is appalling if nokia continue to make phones this bad they'll go bust!

  • Gopi A

    Hey!

    Glad I found this..got my e52 yesterday (India) and the leaks freaked me out.
    The one below the Home key's really unacceptable..can anything be done about it (write to Co, etc)?
    Great review! One thing that really bugs me is how the T9 on the e52 seems to have been made for another world (I got a 2GB card!).

    -Gopi A.

  • Aaaaaaaa

    I also have E52, but in mine light leaks only in 2 places. I find irritating too small buttons-I have small hands but even for me they’re far too small. I can’t imgine writing an email on this phone… writing sms is so uncomfortable, how am I suppose to write sth longer?? Have no idea :) But I still like my phone.

Maemo-Guru.com Shop For Maemo Gear

Archives